Hall of Fame
• A four-year letterwinner who played in 216 games from 2006-09.
• Hit .323 with 52 doubles, eight triples, 47 home runs and 187 RBI.
• His 47 career homers rank first at Canisius and third-best in MAAC history, while he also ranks fourth in MAAC history with 187 career RBI and fifth in the league's record book with 202 runs scored (as of Feb. 2020).
• The 2009 MAAC Player of the Year and a two-time American Baseball Coaches Association All-Regional First Team honoree, he was voted All-MAAC two times in his career.
• After graduating from Canisius, Mahoney was drafted in the 23rd round of the 2009 MLB Draft by the New York Yankees.